This morning I had a conversation with a good friend. We were talking about gender-specific traits and how what is culturally acceptable to one gender, isn’t allowed to be expressed by the opposite gender. Yet in the same breath, those specific traits are also not celebrated or appreciated by society within the specified gender.
For example, if a man is confident and assertive, he’s being “patriarchal;” but if he’s being emotive and vulnerable, then he’s being “weak.” If a woman is being emotive, she needs to “calm down” and if she’s being assertive, she’s being a “b—-.” Translation: no one wins.
Herein lies the problem. We take words and define what we think they should mean, accepting what society dictates is “normal.” We act like personality traits, emotions, and expressions are binary, and then shame people when they do or don’t express our specific definition and categorization of those traits. This oftentimes creates a chaotic blend of contradiction which leaves people hurt, confused, and less willing to communicate.
The reality is, we were each created in the image of God, and women were not called to bare half of the fruits of the Spirit, and men the other half. Those fruits: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, gentleness, faithfulness, and self-control are not binary, and should always be encouraged and celebrated regardless of the gender of who is expressing them. To be a male who is gentle and kind isn’t weakness- it’s sanctification and therefor strength.
To quote Sam Allberry in What God Has to Say about Our Bodies:
“…true, biblical masculinity and true, biblical femininity are, respectively, simply what naturally emerges when men and women grow in Christ. Biblically speaking, masculinity is what long-term sanctification produces in Christian men and femininity what long-term sanctification produces in women.”
As another specific example, I am a huge fan of the words that the Lord continues to give Preston Morrison, and listen regularly to his podcast The Leader’s Cut. I’ve never heard a man express such intimate love for the Father, cry, laugh, be honest, be convicted, and so unashamedly emote when he is deeply moved by something or someone. Yet I would not consider him weak or “feminine” at all- in spite of all the emotions he regularly displays; emotions which are counter-culture to what society dictates is an acceptable level for a man. In fact, his deep, steadfast love for Jesus and the Church is what Sam was talking about when he stated that biblical masculinity was the result of long-term sanctification.
This may be a different perspective, but I’m tired of listening to my male friends complain about being crapped on for being sensitive, and my female friends complain about being crapped on for not being aggressive enough. We tell the gentle to be assertive, and the strong to be weak. What if gentleness was someone’s superpower? What if being strong was? How about instead of treating personality and expressions as binary, we instead ask the Lord for wisdom to see the heart of the person standing in front of us.
Thank you for coming to my TedTalk.